Three forms keep drawing poets back: the villanelle, the sestina, and the ghazal. Each leans on repetition, yet each does something different with it. One locks you into a tight rhyme scheme and two refrains. One sends six words spinning through thirty-nine lines. One lets every couplet stand alone, then binds them with a shared refrain. Knowing how they differ—in difficulty, length, rhyme, and how editors receive them—can help you choose the right vessel for the poem you actually want to write.
The Villanelle: Repetition with a Vengeance
The villanelle is the most compact of the three. Nineteen lines: five tercets and a closing quatrain. It uses only two rhymes, and two refrains. The first line of the poem (A1) and the third line of the first tercet (A2) alternate as the closing lines of each subsequent tercet, then appear together as the final two lines of the quatrain. The pattern looks like this: A1 b A2 / a b A1 / a b A2 / a b A1 / a b A2 / a b A1 A2. Strict, musical, and unforgiving.
Difficulty: high. The refrains must sound inevitable, yet their meaning needs to shift as the poem progresses. If they don't, the poem feels like a cage. Length: short, which is a mercy. Rhyme: two rhyme sounds, so you must find many words that fit. Publication appeal: strong. Editors know the form, and a good villanelle can anchor a submission. Dylan Thomas's "Do Not Go Gentle into That Good Night" is the famous example; Elizabeth Bishop's "One Art" shows how the form can handle loss with dry wit. Both are worth reading aloud to feel how the refrains gather weight.
Tip: write your two refrains first. They should be lines you can imagine saying in different tones—anger, resignation, tenderness. If they only work one way, keep looking.
The Sestina: Six Words, Thirty-Nine Lines
The sestina is longer and stranger. Thirty-nine lines: six sestets and a three-line envoi. There is no rhyme. Instead, six end-words repeat in a fixed order. If the first stanza ends with words 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, the next stanza ends with 6, 1, 5, 2, 4, 3, and so on. The pattern is called retrogradatio cruciata. The envoi uses all six words, usually three at the end of each line and three somewhere inside.
Difficulty: high. The length alone is a test, and the repeated words can become a tic. But because there is no rhyme, you have more freedom in the middle of lines. Length: 39 lines. Rhyme: none. Publication appeal: editors respect the ambition. A well-made sestina stands out, but a mechanical one is easy to spot. Elizabeth Bishop's "Sestina" is the model for many poets: its end-words—house, grandmother, child, stove, almanac, tears—feel both ordinary and charged. The poem earns its repetitions.
Tip: choose end-words that can work as different parts of speech or carry multiple meanings. "Light" can be a noun, verb, or adjective. "Home" can be a place, a feeling, a return. Write the words in a column, then draft lines that end with them. Don't worry about sequence at first; you can rearrange later.
The Ghazal: Couplets in Conversation
The ghazal is the most flexible of the three, though it has its own demands. Traditionally, it is a series of at least five couplets. Each couplet ends with the same refrain (the radif), preceded by a rhyme (the qafia). The first couplet rhymes both lines; every subsequent couplet rhymes only the second line. So the pattern is aa, ba, ca, da, and so on. The couplets are autonomous—they don't need to tell a continuous story. They can leap between moods, images, and subjects. Often the final couplet includes the poet's name or a signature (the takhalus).
Difficulty: moderate to high. Because each couplet stands alone, you can revise them one at a time. The challenge is the refrain: it must feel fresh with every repetition, and the rhyme must not sound forced. Length: flexible—five to fifteen couplets is common. Rhyme: one rhyme sound per poem, plus the refrain. Publication appeal: growing. English-language journals now publish ghazals regularly, but editors notice when a poet has engaged with the form's history rather than treating it as a rhyme game. Agha Shahid Ali's ghazals are a fine starting point; he wrote in English while honouring the Urdu tradition.
Tip: write more couplets than you need. Twenty, then choose the best seven. The refrain should be a short phrase that can shift meaning: "the light," "I remember," "not yet." Avoid couplets that simply restate the previous one.
Side by Side: Difficulty, Length, Rhyme, Appeal
Here's a quick comparison to keep on your desk.
- Difficulty: Villanelle—high, because of the refrains. Sestina—high, because of length and repetition. Ghazal—moderate to high, because of the refrain and rhyme.
- Length: Villanelle—19 lines. Sestina—39 lines. Ghazal—usually 10–30 lines (5–15 couplets).
- Rhyme: Villanelle—two rhymes, strict. Sestina—none. Ghazal—monorhyme with a refrain.
- Publication appeal: Villanelle—familiar and often sought. Sestina—respected, but can feel like a stunt if forced. Ghazal—growing, especially when the poet understands its roots.
- Best for: Villanelle—obsessive emotion, return, refusal. Sestina—meditative, circular themes, family history. Ghazal—lyrical leaps, longing, wit, fragmented beauty.
A Practical Order of Operations
If you want to try all three, here's a sensible sequence.
- Read ten examples of the form you're attempting. Read them aloud. Notice where the repetitions feel natural and where they strain.
- Start with the ghazal if you're new to repeating forms. Its couplets are short, and you can stop at five. Write the refrain first, then draft couplets without worrying about order.
- Move to the villanelle. Write both refrains as lines that can change meaning. Draft the tercets quickly, then revise the rhyme words. Don't settle for near-rhymes unless you're deliberately using them.
- Attempt the sestina last. Choose six end-words that are common enough to use naturally but rich enough to surprise you. Write the first stanza, then the last (the envoi), then fill the middle.
- Revise by reading aloud. If a repetition draws attention to itself for the wrong reason, change the line, not the form.
The Form That Fits Your Poem
No form is better than another. The villanelle suits a mind that circles one thought. The sestina suits a mind that wanders and returns. The ghazal suits a mind that jumps, jokes, and grieves in the same breath. If you're submitting, read the journal first: some editors love formal poems, others prefer them in small doses. A well-made villanelle or ghazal can open a door; a sestina can show you're serious. But the poem comes first. Choose the form that lets you say what you need to say, then let the repetitions do their work. And if the form starts to feel like a cage, step back. The best repeating poems feel like inevitability, not effort.
Photo: cottonbro studio / Pexels
